Question:
Graphic Design or Illustration?
?
2011-11-09 13:55:16 UTC
I am a student currently doing an Art Foundation. About one week ago we were all asked which pathway we would like to pursue in, and I picked Graphics & Illustration. Now at this stage, we are asked to chose which one of the two we would like to specify in - Graphic Design OR Illustration.
I absoloutely love both subjects areas. I enjoy elements of Graphic Design such as typography, communicating a message through a simple design, designing posters and using software such as Adove Illustrator and Photoshop. But I also really enjoy elements of Illustration such as using pencils, fine liners, other markers and watercolours.
This decision will determine what I will be doing for the remainder of my course (about 8 months) - so this decision can't be a bad one.
I don't know which one to chose! Please help?!
Five answers:
?
2011-11-09 18:03:42 UTC
Ultimately we can't make that choice for you. While you may have to make a choice now for school, that doesn't mean you can't do both after school. I will say that it's easier to become a designer and then also start getting into illustration later than it is to become an illustrator and then start getting into design. I hope that makes sense.
Marjorie
2016-05-16 02:31:43 UTC
In my opinion and experience, I offer that illustration is a component of graphic design. In a layout that includes an illustration, that figure must fit in place for the best impact on the observer's eye. A page must flow and an graphic must be scaled and placed in such a way that it does not interrupt that flow. Even if the eye is meant to linger on the illustration, the flow can be continuous, moving around the figure, before going on to other parts, or to the end. A good designer knows a bit about psychology to be able to create effective layouts, and the placement of any graphic element, whether illustration, photograph or typeography uses this knowledge. In an ideal situation, the illustrator would be the designer of the layout, so that the graphic can be created in such a way as to fit the page, rather than the layout be arranged to accomodate the graphic. Next best situation would be that the illustrator and the designer work closely, in order to avoud compromises that detract from page's intention. In any case, both, the graphic designer and the illustrator must know the elements of good composition, so that the page "conflicts" are usually kept to a minimum. I, too, love to draw, and consider myself an excellent illustrator. But business demands mean that I must be flexible, and my training as a graphic designer means that I don't have to turn away clients, whatever they may need. It means that if a client needs a graphic, and can't afford to pay me for original artwork, then I must resort to clip art of someone ELSE'S work, and make it fit in the client's layout. It's a fact of professional, commercial, life, and, both, the graphic artist and the illustrator bring their, separate, expertise to the game. So many of the answers, here, have got it SO wrong, such as "Peter K"s response that illustration has no type. I've done plenty such illustrations, including logos, sign painting, book covers, etc. Or, "kathiekai"s suggestion that graphic design did not exist before computers. The appelation of "artist" appies to the designer, as well as the illustrator.
?
2011-11-10 14:55:07 UTC
I'm the same as you - I love both graphics and illustration, if you enjoy the mixed media side of illustration you could always take graphic design and just use traditional media for whatever you want to create?



At my college Graphics and Illustration are combined but you have to choose between an illustration brief or graphic design brief...



I chose to do book covers for my first project and did it all by hand using a mixture of inks, paints, materials and collage. And then for my major project I did an art magazine cover, article and an illustration poster and with both specialism projects I got to do a mixture of graphic design and illustration, although I had chosen to specialise in Graphic Design.



So maybe you could do something like that? so if you do posters, you could do illustrations for them or use traditional media and what...



Hope this helps and good luck with the rest of your course :)
jplatt39
2011-11-09 14:16:30 UTC
I'd rather answer after looking at your drawings. Ask your teacher. But it's easier to do a good graphic design portfolio with an illustration background than vice versa -- you need good design AND good rendering skills for illustration.
anonymous
2011-11-09 14:16:20 UTC
I would choose Graphic Design. It sounds more fun and interesting.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...